One of Ben Bova's best

I've now read or listened to all of Dr. Bova's "Grand Tour" series and "Mercury" is second only to "Saturn" in my book. It has all the great themes and characters you expect from Bova, deftly exploring what some see as the un-avoidable conflict between science and religion, and others may view as nut cases versus normal people (you decide which is which). It's a little faster paced than "Saturn", and there are a few of the same characters (unfortunately no Poncho Lane in this book). The recording technique of using 3 or 4 different voices really adds drama and atmosphere to the narration. Overall very entertaining as well as thought provoking.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

12 people found this helpful

One of Bova's Best

This is one of my favorite Ben Bova books. The use of three narrators was very effective. I love listening to Stefan Rudnicki - he really brings the characters to life. Arte Johnson and Moira Quirk also did very well. I was so looking forward to listening to someone read the description of the collapse of the sky tower and I was not disappointed.

Someone really needs to make a movie based on this book. Can you imagine the fun the special effects team would have with the collapse of the sky tower? And how much fun it would be to watch it?!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The Best! Loved it!

If you could sum up Mercury in three words, what would they be?

Very interesting and fast paced!

Who was your favorite character and why?

the engineer who built the elevator.

Have you listened to any of the narrators’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

Stephan is just the best in the World!

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

Mercury

Any additional comments?

Ben Bova is a fantastic writer, and important for our time as a cultural leader.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

One of the best in the series

Started a bit slowly, but the twists and turns are worth the patience. Really takes you through the whole gamut of emotions with the characters.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Phenomenal

My favorite book by Been Bova thus far and one of the best science fiction stories I've ever encountered.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A grand story in the traditions of Ben Bova

Ben Bova has become one of my favorite Science Fiction writers. Mercury, like many of Ben Bova's other books, is written around the same future history and events (e.g.,Saturn, Jupiter, etc) but is mostly about other topics and event and not so much about the planet Mercury itself. The motivation for the main character was revenge, which I found too shallow a motivation for such an otherwise intelligent character, but overall, the books themes and events kept me listening to the end. I'd have preferred a better set of outcomes, but I didn't write the book so didn't get to choose the endings. I'd read this book again if I had it to do over again.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Count of Monte Christo?

I thought that a book called Mercury would actually be about Mercury. But, the planet only takes a small portion of the book's length. The rest is a revenge plot, most of which unwinds in flashback. Is it a tragedy or a love story, or both? The plot has shades of twisted romantic love, career, greed, and religion gone awry. In the end, i found myself looking for the Count of Monte Christo.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Well performed dissapointment

Bova was well known for his science but MERCURY was a dissapoint to me. His description of a 'skytower', it's collapse, and Mercury's sun was dissapointinly flawed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Bait and Switch

MORALITY DOESN'T COME IN SHADES OF GRAY
I got this book for two reasons: 1. Bova's book Venus had a scene in it that actually made me feel that I was in the atmosphere of Venus. 2. Mercury seems to be the forgotten planet, few people ever write about it, so I wanted to learn more about it. As it turns out this book is a soap opera and only about 1% of the story takes place on Mercury. Instead it is a story about a space elevator built on Earth. I guess Bova did not believe Clarke (several times), Robinson, Benford, Fortschen, Reynolds, Steele, McDevitt, Niven, Sawyer, Heinlein, Baxter and many others had done a good enough job writing about space elevators, he had to spend the majority of his book, supposedly about Mercury, writing about a space elevator on Earth. He could not even do like Robinson did and build it on the planet in question.

IT'S ALWAYS BETTER TO BE LUCKY THEM SMART
To prove this saying, Bova has one of main characters have so many good luck consequences that have to happen to make the soap opera continue happen that it will make your head spin. He follows this up by making another main character be so stupid it is annoying and he has to be stupid for the so called plot to go forth. He gets an anonymous e-mail from someone about an important science discovery and he does not think twice about it be anonymous. He does not even think about why it was sent to him, a fairly unimportant scientist. His wife says she has gotten a lot of love letters from him, which he sent none, he does not question this either. Most Bova book reviews go on about his science credentials, yet he often writes soap operas instead. Usually there are lots of science to go with the poorly written drama. This book does not even do that. There is some science that is inserted like readings from a dictionary.

ABSENCE OF PROOF IS NOT PROOF OF ABSENCE
Having said all this, the book is not a total loss. I did listen all the way through. It has some interesting parts, such as the dictionary inserts and the discussions on science and it's consequences. I was also surprised by a small statement he made which is just glanced over. In his future earth, he has Israel eliminated and he says the Middle East is a lot more peaceful because of it. It is quick and he does not dwell on it, but a pretty brave statement. (Not saying I agree, but always happy to see an author take a chance and do the politically incorrect thing.)

So, if your interested in reading another book on the space elevator being built on Earth, you might enjoy this or if you like really bad soap opera, you will love this.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

14 people found this helpful

Excellent Bova!

This is more of a "Mature brand" of Sci-fi. Bova does an excellent job of mixing politics, religion, and "human characters" to tell the story...

No.. There's not a lot of laser blasts and desperate daring-do, but it's mature science fiction for those of us that enjoy the real life "Grey areas" of human character, and thinking about what is possible in the not-so-distant future.

As in real life, there is no clear-cut good and evil, and you start out feeling one way, change what you may have believed about midway, and then change your mind again at the end... It's not some mushy "And they lived Happily ever after" story, as so many stories are... it shows the fallible nature of humans, their grand achievements, and their capability for evil.

If it were a paper book, I'd say it was a "page turner"... but since it was an audio book, I found myself wishing they'd read faster in many parts. The innocent aren't so innocent, and the guilty may not be so guilty, or maybe more than guilty, depending on your personal point of view.

I have to say, I was not a big fan of Bova in his early years, but I've yet to listen to a more recent book that has left me wanting. I may have to get "Saturn" despite some of it's poor customer reviews, since the rest of the books in the series have provided me MANY hours of entertainment, and that's ultimately what it's all about..

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful