Worth the time

At first I was concerned that this book would be dry. Instead I found it a vivid portrait of the times surrounding WWI. As a Christian, I cannot help but disagree with the authors worldview, and it saddened me that she never came to know or acknowledge God. However, her insights on the effect of the Great War on herself, her peers, and her country make this book well worth the time spent listening. Highly recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Testament Of More Than Youth

If you really want to get a sense of the utter loss and devastation wrought by WWI, you'd be hard pressed to do better than to read this memoir. Just be prepared for death after death after death. There's more to the memoir than the war and I admit that I wasn't as interested in the build up and the follow-up as I was in the war years section. The build up is of course necessary to understand the depth of the relationships and the therefore the depth of the loss. And I think the follow up was just as important to understand how the survivors did their surviving. Still, the pages dedicated to the war itself were the most gripping. Ultimately a Testament of and to so many things: youth, tragedy, grief, surviving, sacrifice, and one of the ever greatest follies ever perpetrated by those in power. #WWI

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

incredibly intimate glimpse into life during WW1

I went into Testament of Youth blind. I knew nearly nothing about the book, up to and including the fact that it was a memoir of WW1. I would not have read the book if it wasn't chosen by my Reading the World group, but I am so glad that it was because the book is phenomenal.

My family is a big military family. All of us have served. I am a USAF veteran as is my dad. All of my uncles were in the Army. My brother served in the Marines. I have a nephew who is currently in the Coast Guard, and my grandfather served on the battlefields of WW1 in Europe. I know very little about his experiences as he refused to talk about it to anyone. This month I feel like I learned far more about him because I read this book and All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque. In combination I got a very extensive insight into that era.

But for this book the part that most touched me was her feminism. She was a strong, smart, compassionate woman who believed that all women should have the same opportunities in life as men did. And she was fighting for those rights 100 years ago. I admire her.

The early part of the book explored her youth, prior to WWi. She wrote about it with such vivid imagery that it felt like being there and really knowing it. This section allowed me to get to know her as a character, and it also gave me insight into the societal changes that were occurring in Europe. And the examination of how family life was different from the norms of today was very eye-opening. She wrote about the lack of privacy for women and girls, and how they were never allowed to have moments alone. This section is where we start to get an inkling that Brittain is not the submissive girl she is expected to be and that she will be a woman we can all respect.

Brittain became a VAD nurse at only 18. She fell in love (more than once). She lost lovers and a brother to the war. She saw PTSD up close. She understood and explained the war in a way that allowed me to also understand it. And although she explains the war era with a quiet resolve and little emotion, there are moments when she allows her hatred of the war to show.

"I wish those people who write so glibly about this being a holy War, and the orators who talk so much about going on no matter how long the War lasts and what it may mean, could see a case--to say nothing of 10 cases--of mustard gas in its early stages--could see the poor things burnt and blistered all over with great mustard-coloured suppurating blisters, with blind eyes--sometimes temporally, sometimes permanently--all sticky and stuck together, and always fighting for breath, with voices a mere whisper, saying that their throats are closing and they know they will choke.

And the book does not end when the war ends. Brittain allows us to see what post-war life looks like for her. She allows us to see the changes that war has made to her. And, for me this was the most successful and powerful part of the book. It is the section that most solidified my hatred of war. This is where I found my grief and compassion for my grandpa, who is long dead.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

9 people found this helpful

A bitter sweet historical drama

I found myself wanting to read this book having recently seen the movie. I enjoyed the movie and the book both very much for somewhat slightly different different reasons. The tragic truth of her experience edit entire generation of pre-world war one youthHe’s only been more sad knowing how it is followed by the depression and World War II. There’s something to be learned of humanity from Vera britton’s experience.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Great book!!!

It was an amazing read! Loved it so much. I couldn't stop listening! What an awesome experience.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Moving and informative WWI memoir

I appreciated Brittain’s feminism, her pacifism, her religious skepticism, her sharing of her thoughts. This memoir is informative about WWI, while also presenting a very personal view of life during the war years, the sacrifices of her generation for an unclear purpose. Sadly, though she had hopes about what could be learned to prevent further devastation, that did not happen. We also see the slow progress that women made in achieving equal rights, and, sadly, too, a 100 years later, though women have far more options, there is still so much to accomplish. The narrator could have been far better. I didn’t mind so much the older sounding voice (as some reviewers commented, and, indeed she was quite elderly) but I do agree with all the reviewers who complained that she dropped her voice. I too frequently had to wind back and increase the volume just so I could catch the end of sentences. This detracted from the listening. But you should persist - the book is worth listening to.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Narrator difficult to understand

I had really been looking forward to listening to this book. All my friends and family loved it. Unfortunately, however, I found the reader to be extremely difficult to understand. I could make out only about 85% of the words. This has nothing to do with British accent. I have listened to hundreds of audible accents, including many British narrators. Eventually I had to abandon the book. It is too good a book to be so frustrating. I will have to get someone to read it to me.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Couldn’t even finish

Made it through only five chapters. Somehow the character is still bogged down whining about feelings of inferiority at Oxford while simultaneously giggling over her new boy crush. Mistakenly thought this was a gritty WWI memoir.

The narrator completely ruins it as well. Sounds like a 2-pack-per-day smoker. She also either drops off completely at the end of her sentences or drops her voice so low she can’t be understood.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Old Favorite With Issues

I read Testament of Youth and Testament of Experience in print ages ago and loved them both. This edition is accompanied by introductions and explanations from the author's daughter and the author herself. I was excited to have an audio version of the book and looked forward to a long happy listen.

My problem lies in the fact that the narration makes the author sound like a haughty arrogant very old dowager. The listening is tough going as Mitchell, the narrator, allows her voice to drop off at the end of sentences and rushes through the cumbersome and complex ornate prose. This mix makes hearing what is being read difficult and understanding the words at times almost impossible.

This book was first published when the author was in her late 30's looking back at her experience of life before WWI and the impact the war had on her generation. The voicing the narrator uses sounds too old. I had come to think that this was the only voice Mitchell was capable of--then at the two hour point when the journal entries entered the picture--she switched to a young woman's voice for these portions--so this elderly voice seems to have been a choice. What a shame, because the younger clear voice made the elderly voice even worse by comparison.

I think the problem lies in that the author's intro for the 1970's edition was written when Brittain was 80 years old. It seems that production for this recording assumed the whole book should be voiced by an eighty year old instead of the age Brittain actually was when the book was written. This error makes listening to this recorded version impossible for me.

If you read the reviews on Amazon for the print edition you will find an even bigger debate going on over the content of the book. Reviewers sounding off, arguing about and judging what Brittain says--not how the narrator voices the story. To me, this is a book from history and about the author's personal thoughts, beliefs and perceptions. You may find many of her assumptions offensive--but I think they represent the culture of the time. I do agree with several reviewers in that Brittain was very contradictory in her opinions and to me that just exposes the "youth" from the title of the book.

This book is still an excellent look at one person's experience of WWI--even with its flaws. However, the unfortunate narration makes it impossible for me to hear and understand the words. Listen carefully to the sample before you decide and keep in mind that the actual narration is even worse than the sample suggests.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

52 people found this helpful

could not understand reader

the reader was very difficult to understand. I finally gave up at about 20 minutes in.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!