Story okay, performance was good

Repeating signifiers: He/she murmurs, growls, orders, was irritating to me personally. The story had an overall interesting concept but was handled with lopsided grace. It doesn't leave me wanting to read the next book, but if I didn't have anything else to listen to, I'd try it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Amazing

this book was amazing. can't wait to read the rest. it reminded me a little of Catching Fire

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Great Job!

Amy is great at telling stories. I love her writing style. The book was very engaging. I recommend the book and look forward to the next book

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Mixed bag for me...

3 stars — Oh dear. Where to start. There were glimmers of interesting things going on, but not really enough to suck me in and make up for what *wasn’t* working for me.

We’ll start with the narrator. Ms. Reinders was solidly in the okay category. She didn’t grate on my nerves, there was some inflection, but I needed something more from her to make her stand out. In the end I think listening to the story was a bit of a disservice, because while she doesn’t have a flat narration style, there wasn’t enough emotion and interest to really allow me to connect with Roselle. Honestly, it was flat enough that I started to notice sentences being all the same length, which is not something I’m usually attuned to. In addition, her other character voices left me underwhelmed. There wasn’t always a lot of difference in them, and while I thought she did an okay Hawthorne and Agent Crow, I found her choice for Clifton to be…odd. It made him sound flighty or something. I’m not entirely sure what she was going for, but apparently it didn’t work for me. If I decide to read the rest of the trilogy, I *won’t* be listening to them.

I’m usually all about the characters in books, and part of the reason this book didn’t get rated higher is that I didn’t connect with any of them in this story. I didn’t find Roselle to be that interesting of a character, and there was nothing for me to relate to. We’re told a lot of her stellar qualities, but we don’t necessarily see them in action. I appreciated her complete mastery of all things soldier/fighting, but outside of that she was a conundrum. She would have these amazing moments where she would quip a witty retort to some a**hat, and then she’d be all meek and supposedly helpless. It didn’t work. I couldn’t personally make it work in my head. I needed more consistency from her.

And OMG, I think I might have to give up on Ms. Bartol, even though I adore her in person. She LOVES making her heroines universally loved/lusted by EVERY SINGLE MALE IN THE BOOK. That’s not my bag baby. It’s why I haven’t finished any of her series actually. I don’t relate to that, I don’t get it, it doesn’t make any of her relationships special, and it doesn’t make her stand out (even though that is its *exact* purpose). As for this story, I didn’t connect with a single one of her suitors. The relationship with Hawthorne developed at LIGHTSPEED and was completely unbelievable to me. What in the world did they bond over? It felt superficial and rushed. And Hawthorne was just another bland hero trying to save the girl. Meh.

As for Clifton and Reykin (whom I’m assuming are the other two potential love interests), nothing much sets them apart either. Clifton comes across kind of older and creepy and possessive…though there was a glimmer of depth near the end. I wish we’d seen more of *that*. Reykin…well, honestly I have no idea. Maybe we’ll know more in the next books.

As per usual, there are essentially no other strong female characters, no female friends for Roselle to rely on. I’ve started noticing this since it’s been pointed out to me, and it’s disappointing when it’s missing.

Agent Crow was creepy as *beep*, so well done on the villain. Though I honestly prefer a more subtle villain myself, Crow was a bit over the top for me.

So besides characters/chemistry, what does that leave us? World building and plot/action. And this was a mixed bag for me. There were SO MANY DETAILS to keep straight that I honestly got overwhelmed, and I’m still confused. But at the same time, what I did understand fascinated me, and sets itself up for some interesting future machinations! Honestly, while characters are the thing for me, if I have an amazing world/plot to fall back on, it can make up for it and still blow me away. This one wasn’t quite there, hence the middling rating. I was just left with a lot more questions: how did this world come to be this way? What was the purpose of the factions? How long has this birth order thing been a thing?

So yeah. Super mixed bag. If I hadn’t gotten the rest of the trilogy from NetGalley, I wouldn’t have hesitated in abandoning the series. It’s interesting, but not mind-blowing. However, I *do* have the rest in ARCs, so now I’m torn. Perhaps I’ll at least try the next book and see if I get more of the good stuff…

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Great book!

I loved the story and can't wait for the next one to come onto audio.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

interesting & entertaining book

It took a bit for the story & characters to capture me, but when it did, I was all in! I am looking forward to book 2.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

AMAZING MUST READ! - ALREADY PRE-ORDERED BOOK 2!

Would you consider the audio edition of Secondborn to be better than the print version?

This was an amazing sci-fi book - and that's saying a lot, b/c I do NOT like sci-fi!! The characters were endearing and you really loved rooting for some - and hating others! It is a definite recommendation whether you enjoy the sci-fi genre or not!!

What about Kate Reinders’s performance did you like?

I loved how she really differentiated between characters, and I always knew who was talking. She made you FEEL what they were feeling and experiencing as well! Will watch for her in the future!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Narrator seems to miss it

I love the story line. It was well written and the author did fairly well at verbal illustration for the complex world the characters lived in. However, I feel that the Narrator seemed not to be able to convey certain nuances of emotion that I feel were implied by the wording. I feel that many such times the narrator's performance was flat.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent read!

This is a very well written book! Great characters and the story line keeps you riveted.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Can’t get enough of this dystopian society

When I first started listening to Secondborn, I wasn’t sure if I would want to finish it. However, Amy Bartol has me completely entrance in this dystopian society. This is a perfect mix between The Hunger Games and Divergent, with enough differences to become its own world. It’s amazing. I finished the first two books of the series within two days only to find out after a huge and heart wrenching cliffhanger, the third book doesn’t have an audio book! 😭 will definitely listen to again! Kate Reinders did a great job narrating! ❤️

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!