Good story; odd narration <br /><br /><br />

I enjoyed the story, but I plan to avoid any other books by this narrator

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Narrator made this impossible to complete

I was excited to find a Finnish crime series with so many titles to keep me listening through the winter waiting for another season of Bordertown -I love stories that connect me to my family in Finland. It’s possible that some of the issues are translation problems, but this narrator is impossible to listen to. I agree with other reviews that she sounded like the text-to-audio narration but a few chapters in she seemed to loosen up a bit. But the pronunciation of names is ridiculous. I’ve listened to other Nordic novels narrated with excellent pronunciation of people and place names. This was just lazy reading on top of a storyline that was so wildly implausible that I couldn’t get past chapter 4. Sad to let this whole series go, but there’s so much better available in this genre.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good book... LOUSY narrator!

The narrator was so bad that I can’t listen to her anymore and I deleted all the sequels to this book I already bought... VERY disappointing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

First Published 1993 So Expect Some Social Change

Maria Kallio is a young sergeant in the Serious Crime Unit in Helsinki, Finland. The book was first published in 1993 so if it seems socially a bit off that is probably the reason. Maria is trying to decide her career path. She is divided between the police work she originally considered her goal-- she naively wanted to help both victims and criminals-- and an interest in practicing law, the current goal of her education. When the book opens she is engaged in a six month temporary assignment with the police

Her immediate supervisor is hors de combat due to his alcoholism. Her coworker is about to go on vacation and has made it clear that nothing is going to stand between him and his vacation, least of all a newly reported body found floating beside a dock connected to a summer villa. At first it seems the death might be the cause of an accident. Then it becomes Maria's first murder.

This is a procedural not an action packed adventure. Maria interviews all of the potential suspects and witnesses as she looks deeper into the case. There's connections within connections as it seems that everyone is somehow involved in more than one way with everyone else.

The narrator is quite authoritative when it comes to the names-- Finnish is not a language that people in the US tend to be familiar with by ear so hearing the names is quite helpful. Also most of the main characters have short first names which helps with keeping them straight.

All of the Finns I have met tend to be avid readers and when speaking English rarely use colloquialisms. I think that the dialogue in the book which is described as "wooden" by at least one reviewer is an accurate translation. It's one of those cases I guess where the translator must choose a between accuracy and accessibility in another language. I don't think choosing accuracy was a mistake.

So if you are thinking about listening to this book you might want to try a sample first.

I'm very pleased that AmazonCrossing and Brilliance Audio are making these translated works available to a wider audience.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Narrator Put Me To Sleep With Monotone

I rarely read a print book and love Audible, but this might be a better book to skip audio and go for paper. If I'd read instead of listening, I may have added one more star by avoiding the narrator, but too late to test that now, I wouldn't pay 2 times to read this book. I use Audible because most times, the narration enriches the book, not here.

I was put off by the social interaction Maria had with the suspects, there's no way she'd be assigned this case in real life because of being connected to most of the suspects. I got tired of lines like: I shouldn't be out drinking with this *insert suspect name here* even with a "let's not talk about the case" caveat. And enough of the nonstop trips to the machine for thin hot chocolate, filler. If I was reading this I could scan past things like the hot chocolate complaints and move on, but that monotone voice just drones on and no way to easily bypass like your brain would do with a book in front of eyeballs. If the cocoa is so bad, quit mentioning she runs to the machine every time her brain needs a break.

I wrote the narrator's name on my "avoid in the future" list.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A rookie investigator may be in over her head.

Everything about Maria Kallio is tentative: She has yet to finish a degree she's not sure she wants. She has a place to live only because her relatives let her stay there while the apartment market is down. She has a job with the police, but it's terrible - and temporary. She doesn't much care for it, except as a livelihood, and she seems not particularly good at it: She is socially awkward, and gets too emotionally involved. But it's just a job, and not a great one, at that, so all she has to do is keep her head down, not screw up, and she'll be out of there soon enough. Then she gets reluctantly put in charge of a major case. Can she actually see this one thing through to the end?

This is a very brief first novel in a series about Maria Kallio. I liked the way the main character's "awkward age" is portrayed against a cast of suspects at a similar stage in life. The simple drudgery and distractions of police work are also described well, and played off against the crime-solving and "character" aspects of the story in an effective manner.

The narrator has a lovely voice and her delivery is very well-suited to the character.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Decent story, disappointing performance

I enjoyed the novel as a first venture. Interesting story line and good character development. The reader is very disappointing, seems to be trying for soap opera-like excitement with a breathy voice that has no range. I won't choose audible if sge is the reader of the next book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Series off to a weak start

My First Murder is Book 1 of the 6 book Maria Kallio audio series. I listened to and reviewed the other five books first. This is by far the weakest novel in this wonderful modern detective suspense thriller series. Some have complained about the narration of Amy Rubinate; I disagree!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

10 people found this helpful

Nitpicking translation use of Imperial measurement

I just find it jarring to hear Finnish characters speaking in miles, feet and pounds. Ya think we can’t figure out the units used in Finland?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Eh.

I really don't think the book would have been too bad if it were a different narrator. I didn't feel like the narrator made any of the character voices different from the main character, so it was really hard to tell when another character was talking until she was over a sentence in, and then it was just confusing. The end of the book felt kind of rushed and all over the place while the beginning and middle dragged on. Best way for me to describe it is, "Meh."

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!