A Brilliant, Hauntingly Beautiful Story Rooted in Love, Loss, and Second Sight

I truly loved Give Them Unquiet Dreams by James Mulhern—a powerful, emotionally rich novel that weaves themes of coming-of-age, spirituality, and the unseen forces that quietly guide us through life. Set in a gritty blue-collar Boston neighborhood, this is more than just a story of one boy’s growth; it’s a poetic exploration of the Irish Catholic spirit, wrapped in both suffering and unwavering love.

At its center is Aiden, a young boy gifted (and burdened) with the “second sight,” who navigates life’s hardest truths with guidance from his grandfather’s spirit and the enduring wisdom of his beloved Nana—“keep calm and carry on.” Their voices echo through the book as Aiden grapples with mental illness, family pride, and the powerful ties that hold generations together. His brother Martin’s loyal reassurance, “I will always have your back, you remember that,” becomes a grounding force in a world teetering between tragedy and grace.

Mulhern captures the heart of a Boston Irish Catholic family with authenticity and reverence. There’s a profound beauty in how the novel explores the line between mental illness and mental brilliance, between dreams and reality. The Irish sensibility—at once morbid and mystical—shines through, revealing that perhaps this gift of “second sight” is simply the Irish way of seeing possibility in the impossible.

One of the most moving insights from Aiden’s grandfather sums it all up: “All time happens at once. No true division between past and future, rather a single existence.” It’s this timelessness that makes the novel feel sacred, as if we’re reading not just about Aiden’s life, but our own dreams and ancestors as well.

A remarkable story, Give Them Unquiet Dreams is a testament to faith, family, and the quiet resilience that keeps our roots strong, even in the face of sorrow. For anyone who has ever longed for deeper meaning in life—or for a message from beyond—this book offers both.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!