The ends justify the means?

I am convinced Giampietro’s memoir would have been VERY pro Hitler had the German’s won the war. Psychologically, the most revealing part of the memoir is where Giampietro confronts his commanding officer, after deciding wearing uniforms of the enemy is dishonorable. Giampietro’s Lieutenant listens to Giampietro’s concerns and then gives a speech that reminded me of a speech a character out of an Ayn Rand novel might make about war. The message in the speech? The ends justify the means. Victors write the history books so it Giampietro’s duty to do what is required to assist Germany to win the war. The Lieutenant persuades Giampietro with his arguments. Giampietro, therefore, decides to stay with the Brandenburger Special Forces unit. As long as Germany is winning the war, Giampietro enthusiastically plays his role in winning the war. As the Third Reich loses the war, Giampietro’s “moral” qualms reappear. Suddenly, the (losing) ends no longer justify the means. I enjoyed this memoir, but more from what it says about us human beings psychologically, spiritually and emotionally than as a war memoir - which is incomplete. Giampieto’s experiences fighting Partisans in Yugoslavia in 1944 is left virtually blank. So are the end of the war details in Italy and elsewhere. Giampietro seems more concerned with the losing “end” and explaining himself morally than he does with the “means” he used from 1943-45 to survive. In this life, there are no “ends.” Only “means.” Please do not interpret this conclusion as a pious, prissy condemnation of Germany during the Second World War. Churchill’s Great Britain; Roosevelt’s United States and Joe stalin’s Soviet Union, were all maneuvering to dominate the world stage - and like Giampietro, their ends justified the means also. Nevertheless, Giampietro’s overall interesting memoir reveals the hopelessness of us human beings as we attempt to negotiate ourselves through this life without the light of God…

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

a heck of a story

really enjoyed this, at times very detailed and very personal account of some of his experiences.

loved the inclusion of the context of being from Süd Tirol

Was disappointed he dis not include more detail of his Italian experiences

however, altogether, a great listen

thank you for sharing Sep

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Pretty amazing story

It has some slow parts but he does a great job painting a picture of the story

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Lost interest fast

Drones on i I listened to 3 chapters and had to give up. Yes. I understand. You are South Tyrollean. For God sake move on..fascinating subject matter made dull is a real accomplishment

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Meh…

This was the worst of the Heir stories I listened to. Any other would be better

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Memoir of a Liar and War Criminal? Perhaps.

This book smells an awful lot like the author, Sepp de Giampietro, wanted to whitewash and hide his true story. The summary boasted that this was an incredible view into the Brandenburgers, the German commandos in WWII. It wasn't incredible, nor was it insightful. They were soldiers that wore enemy uniforms. That's all the more insight the reader/listener gets into that. As for the author, he spends an inordinate amount of time in this "memoir" talking about how much he was against the war and Hitler. I find that hard to believe. To me, it came across as a whitewashing of his personal history, of him fervently denying that he was diehard supporter of the Nazis. I doubt that a ho-hum recruit that questions Hitler and the War Germany is fighting would get picked up by the Brandenburgers, as Sepp claimed he was. I don't think Sepp is entirely truthful in this memoir. Maybe that wasn't so, but there are other oddities about this book that make me believe otherwise.

SPOILER ALERT - the rest of this review will give away the book, so stop here if you want.

Sepp gives a fairly detailed experience of his life before the war, volunteering for service, going through training, and then his battles in Yugoslavia, Greece and Russia. He's then selected for War College and becomes an officer. The next portion of his service, hunting partisans in Yugoslavia (a particularly gruesome location and time of the War) is all of about 1 sentence, something along the lines of, "I went on anti-partisan activity, got shot and returned home." That skimming of a year (or more) of his life certainly didn't go unnoticed by me. That left me feeling cheated and that Sepp was hiding something. The only conclusion I can draw is that he was likely involved in heinous war crimes that he doesn't want to mention and tarnish his life story. Anti-partisan hunting behind the front lines in '43-'44 in Yugoslavia was a dirty business. Yugoslavia was in the midst of a 3-way civil war. Torture and murder on all sides was a common occurrence. I don't see any other reason why an individual would skip such a major portion of his military history and life story that he's documenting in a memoir. At the end of the war, he's captured in Italy. The war is all but over (the time wasn't specific at the end, but it sounded like April 1945 in Italy). He's insistent on escaping the POW camp that he's in and can get no one else to join him. They all seem to know that the quickest way home, especially in the captivity of the Americans, it to just wait it out in the POW camp. Again, Sepp's insistence on escaping (not to rejoin German forces still fighting, but just to run and hide), leads me to believe he's a war criminal worried that his past will be discovered while in captivity. So he escapes and then goes back into detail about his flight. Finally he gets home, but then doesn't say what happens. The book ends right as we find out he's made it to his parent's village. We don't hear what happens to him, it's just over. The book just ends.

I was disappointed. Not a great memoir, and it leaves you with a nagging feeling that you're being lied to about his true life story - ironically lying is something Sepp boasts that he's very good at throughout the book.

Read/listen to with a grain of salt and a healthy does of skepticism.

P.S. - The performance was great. P.J Ochlan is a fantastic narrator that I've enjoyed listening to in several other books. In this one, he uses a very good German accent throughout. Bravo.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Good story terrible narration

No disrespect intended to the veteran. This review is bad due to the horrible narration. The terrible German accent is totally unnecessary.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful